首页 >
法律 >
行政法 >
Judicial Dissent in European Constitutional Courts: A Comparative and Legal Perspective

Judicial Dissent in European Constitutional Courts: A Comparative and Legal Perspective

作者： Katalin Kelemen
出版商： Routledge
ISBN: 9781472482235

出版时间 September 2017
规格： Hardback
适应领域： U.K. ? 免责申明：
Countri(es) stated herein are used as reference only
Paperback Edition ISBN: 9780367336837

￥1,586.25

或

下载订单表

加入收藏
| 加入比较

描述
大纲

详细

Dissent in courts has always existed. It is natural and healthy that judges disagree on legal issues of a certain importance and difficulty. The question is if it is reasonable to conceal dissent. Not every legal system allows judges to explain their disagreement to the public in a separate opinion attached to the judgment of the court. Most constitutional courts do.

This book presents a comparative analysis of the practice of judicial dissent in constitutional courts from the perspective of the civil law tradition. It discusses the theoretical background, presents the history of the institution and today’s practice, thus laying down the basis for an accurate consideration of the phenomenon from a legal perspective.
Introduction
Chapter I: Judicial dissent: What is it and why does it matter?
1. Judicial dissent and dissenting opinions: A definition
2. Judicial dissent in legal research: An object or a tool?
3. The sui generis nature of constitutional courts

Chapter II: The decision-making process in constitutional courts
1. Internal court structure in comparative perspective
2. The prominent figures of the decision-making process
2.1. The president of the Court
2.2. The most prominent members of the decision-making panel: The rapporteur judge and the opinion-writer
2.3. Non-judicial offices: Law clerks and the Secretary General
3. Judicial style in constitutional courts

　
Chapter III: Judicial dissent in the common law tradition
1. Introductory remarks
2. The origins of the dissenting opinion
2.1. The historical roots: England
2.2. The ‘institutionalization’ of judicial dissent in the United States
2.3. The first Great Dissenters in the history of the U.S. Supreme Court
3. The practice of dissenting opinions in the common law tradition: England and the United States
3.1. The decision-making process: Two common law supreme courts compared
3.2. The role of law clerks in the decision-making process
3.3. Separate opinions and the doctrine of binding precedent. The problematic issue of plurality opinions
3.4. Dissent rates and judicial style in the US and the UK Supreme Courts
Chapter IV: Judicial dissent in the civil law tradition
1. Judicial decision-making in the civil law tradition: Founded on secrecy?
2. Judicial dissent in three Western European legal systems
2.1. Dissenting opinions in German constitutional justice
2.1.1. History
2.1.2. Practice
2.2. Voto reservado and voto particular: Dissenting opinions in Spanish constitutional justice
2.2.1. Votos reservadosand votos particulares: The history of judicial dissent in Spain
2.2.2. The practice of dissenting opinions in the Tribunal Constitucional
2.3. Attempts of introducing dissenting opinions in Italian constitutional justice
3. Judicial dissent in the European courts
3.1. Dissenting opinions in Strasbourg. The practice of the European Court of Human Rights
3.2. The absence of dissenting opinions in Luxembourg. The practice of the Court of Justice of the European Union
3.3. Comparative excursus: Dissenting opinions in The Hague. The practice of the International Court of Justice
3.4. Comparative remarks
4. Judicial dissent in East-Central European constitutional courts
4.1. A new generation of constitutional courts: Why to treat them separately?
4.2. Law in the books: The rules concerning judicial dissent
4.2.1. The Baltic story: three degrees of openness
4.2.2. The Slovak story: precedent becomes law
4.2.3. The Yugoslav story: a separate way
4.3. Law in action: The use of dissenting opinions
4.3.1. What do the numbers show?
4.3.2. The role of dissenting opinions in the development of constitutional law
5. A country study: The use of dissenting opinions in the Hungarian Constitutional Court (1990-2010)
5.1. The challenges of a quantitative analysis
5.2. The data on separate opinions from 1990-2010
5.3. The two forms of separate opinion: dissents and concurrences
5.4. Why does a judge decide to write separately?
5.5. The style of separate opinions
5.6. The internal dynamics of decision-making
5.7. When a dissenting opinion becomes precedent
5.8. Conclusion

Chapter V: Comparative reflections
1. The publication of judicial dissent: pros and cons
2. Independence vs. transparency: A difficult balance
2.1. Dissenting opinions and judicial independence
2.2. Dissenting opinions and transparency of decision-making
3. Judicial dissent and legal certainty
3.1. Legitimacy, the majority principle and the ‘consistency’ element of legal certainty
3.2. The ‘predictability’ element of legal certainty
3.3. Legal certainty and the different schools of legal theory
3.4. A brief remark on the indeterminacy of constitutional law
4. The judges’ point of view
4.1. The internal effects of separate opinions
4.2. Judicial dissent and the freedom of expression
5. The role of dissenting opinions in the development of constitutional law
6. Conclusive remarks
Appendix: List of Western and East-Central European Constitutions, Constitutional Court Acts and Rules of Procedure of the respective constitutional courts
Bibliography

你可能需要


The Hong Kong Company Secretary's Handbook: Practice and Procedure (11th Edition): List Price: ￥517.94

￥502.40 Save ￥15.54 (3%)


Hong Kong Tax & Accounting Practical Toolkit (Basic Package): ￥3,420.66


Hong Kong Company Secretary Checklist, 2nd Edition: List Price: ￥1,297.20

￥1,258.28 Save ￥38.92 (3%)


Law of Companies in Hong Kong, 4th Edition (Hardcopy + e-Book): List Price: ￥3,290.00

￥3,191.30 Save ￥98.70 (3%)


Butterworths Hong Kong Discrimination Law Handbook, 4th Edition: List Price: ￥1,410.00

￥1,367.70 Save ￥42.30 (3%)


Sentencing in Hong Kong, 11th Edition: List Price: ￥3,365.20

￥3,264.24 Save ￥100.96 (3%)


Butterworths Hong Kong Company Law (Winding-Up and Miscellaneous Provisions) Handbook, 6th Edition: List Price: ￥2,143.20

￥2,078.90 Save ￥64.30 (3%)


Butterworths Hong Kong Company Law Handbook, 26th Edition: List Price: ￥4,136.00

￥4,011.92 Save ￥124.08 (3%)


Cross-Border Crime in Hong Kong: Extradition, Mutual Assistance & Financial Sanctions, 3rd Edition: List Price: ￥1,955.20

￥1,896.54 Save ￥58.66 (3%)


Clough & Clough on Personal Injuries: List Price: ￥1,410.00

￥1,367.70 Save ￥42.30 (3%)


Hong Kong Personal Insolvency Manual, 3rd Edition: List Price: ￥1,880.00

￥1,823.60 Save ￥56.40 (3%)


Butterworths Hong Kong Conveyancing and Property Law Handbook, 6th Edition: List Price: ￥1,692.00

￥1,641.24 Save ￥50.76 (3%)


A Practical Guide to Resolving Shareholder Disputes, 2nd Edition: List Price: ￥1,692.00

￥1,641.24 Save ￥50.76 (3%)


Tort Law in Hong Kong, 5th Edition (Hardcopy + ebook): List Price: ￥2,350.00

￥2,279.50 Save ￥70.50 (3%)


Company Law in Hong Kong: Practice and Procedure 2023 (Hardcopy + e-Book): List Price: ￥3,006.12

￥2,915.94 Save ￥90.18 (3%)


Company Law in Hong Kong: Insolvency 2023 (Hardcopy + e-Book): List Price: ￥2,672.42

￥2,592.25 Save ￥80.17 (3%)


Hong Kong Company Law, 15th Edition: List Price: ￥462.48

￥448.61 Save ￥13.87 (3%)


Private Equity in Hong Kong and China, 4th Edition: List Price: ￥1,880.00

￥1,823.60 Save ￥56.40 (3%)


Brooke's Notary Hong Kong, 3rd Edition: List Price: ￥1,598.00

￥1,550.06 Save ￥47.94 (3%)


Butterworths Hong Kong Employees' Compensation Handbook, 7th Edition: List Price: ￥1,974.00

￥1,914.78 Save ￥59.22 (3%)

“

Ordering from Professional Bookshop is fantastic, quick delivery great products, great customer service Siti L.
This is a great bookstore and have had no problems with them and all my orders have come on time and in good condition. Yang X.
Everything is perfect. Fast delivery. I highly recommend this website to all my friends and colleagues. Thanks Hoi Man L.
So thankful I am receiving all my books, thank you to all for a great service and excellent products Clinton K.
Professional Bookshop is amazing! I've been a loyal customer for over 5 years. Returns are easy to request, book or delivery complaints are taken seriously and the customer service team is friendly and patient. Mick D.
I wanted to informed you that the customer service is excellent. They were so polite and nice. I would continue to buy books from Professional Bookshop. Jingsong C.
Fast and quick service. Easy transaction method, arrived sooner than expected. Excellent packaging and the books received are in perfect condition! Thank you very much! I love the book and its quality. Saori B.
I can order any accounting books from worldwide from Professional Bookshop. Love this website and save my time to search from internet. Lingxiao R.
It is just so easy to find what you are always looking for and sometimes you can even find it up to 80% off what you would in the normal store. Graeme R.
I love shopping on Professional Bookshop! They have a wide range of accounting book with competent prices. Free shipping in Hong Kong is also really handy! Fergus Y.
Professional Bookshop is a great bookstore, I must say. Buying books in Professional Bookshop is so easy, great and reliable. It is highly recommendable. Deborah D.
A great site to shop accounting books and everything and with discountable prices. It’s my first choice whenever i want to shop something. Most trusted site. Zeng Z.
I found the books I needed and at a very low price. I am very happy and will definitely use it in the future Brian W.
I have been using Professional Bookshop for a while now. I am very impressed with customer service and delivery. When I need to have a return it is done very diligently. Olivia L.
Professional Bookshop is my default go to for finding the best prices and reading details of law books before buying. Detailed book description is very helpful. Tracy W.
I've been using Professional Bookshop since 2011 and they actually great, I always received great service and my book arrives on time. Lisa C.

所有书籍

Judicial Dissent in European Constitutional Courts: A Comparative and Legal Perspective

Free delivery Hong Kong?

详细

你可能需要

What Our Customers Say?

所有书籍

Judicial Dissent in European Constitutional Courts: A Comparative and Legal Perspective

Free delivery Hong Kong?

详细

你可能需要

What Our Customers Say?

video title